Do you do Value Checks? - Also known as "Pre-Comps, Value Checks, Paper Searches, Over the Phone Estimate of Value and "Pre-Appraisals."
Well....... We do, and we don't.
It is impossible, and against USPAP standards, to provide an opinion of value without completion of the appraisal process. Value indicators such as condition, square footage, location, upgrades, repairs needed, views, amenities, and any physical deficiencies, functional or external obsolescence cannot be accurately determined without an inspection.
What we can do:
We can share available sales & listings data near the subject property that may have similar value attributes. These may or may not be the comparable properties that we will use in developing an opinion of value or completing an appraisal report form. None of this data shall be considered any kind of value opinion. Our actual appraised value could be higher, lower, or similar to any sales or listings that we share with you. We can discuss the probability or risk of various market values in a limited way, but ultimately, we can't give a value opinion without full completion of the appraisal process. Any value figures on order forms, such as "owners' estimates of value," will not be targeted. They will be ignored.
If you would find this helpful, just note this on the order form and we will do it prior to setting the appointment for the inspection. If you request it we will fax you a description of some of the proximate sales & listings data that we will be researching further in the appraisal process. These may or may not be the comparables that are most appropriate or the ones that we use in our appraisal report. Of course all of this sales & listing data is not verified and could change once a full inspection/appraisal has been completed.
We will make sure that we consider all upgrades and that the property is not under appraised.
What we cannot do:
We cannot "shoot for" a certain value or "try to get max value." These are illegal assignments.
We will not respond to illegal requests such as "If you can get $xxx,xxx, you can have the appraisal order."
If you are "value shopping" by sending multiple comp check requests to multiple appraisers, we are not your appraisal company, so please take us off your list.
You need to know that we will not accept an assignment in which the paid fee is dependent on any appraisal outcome.
We are happy to some provide market data to help you evaluate the risk of obtaining possible values, but we cannot give a specific opinion or promise a certain value or take an assignment based on obtaining a certain value.
As usual Veracity Realty Service is open minded to all descusions and comments on any topics posted.
How to Prepare for an Appraisal
As you know the appraisal is one of the last necessary factors before a sale or refinance can happen. It allows the property transactions to occur among the buyer, seller, real estate agent and mortgage lender, or is the last step for refinancing.
Before an Appraiser arrives at the subject property, there are a few things you should tell your client. By law, an appraiser must be state licensed to perform appraisals prepared for federally related transactions. Also by law, your client is entitled to receive a copy of the completed appraisal report from you the lender. Since you are my client I cannot release it to them without your expressed written consent. So please let your clients know how they can receive a copy of the appraisal from you.
To facilitate the appraisal process, it's beneficial to have your clients provide these documents to the appraiser at the time of inspection:
Once the appraiser has arrived at the subject property, your clients do not need to accompany him or her along on the entire site inspection, but your client should be available to answer questions about your property and be willing to point out any home improvements.
Here are some other suggestions:
Please note that we all work hard to make sure that the transaction of a sale or refinance goes as smoothly as possible for everyone involved in the transaction. If the property, rooms in the property, or if certain areas of the property can not be accessed this may delay the process and make things more difficult for all. If we all work together, and educate the loan applicant we can make their experience a pleasant one.
Please feel free to comment on this article and state your opinion on how we can make things easier for you..
Thank again for your business,
Jeff.....................
I am often asked about the ways an appraiser determines value within the appraisal report. I thought if I wrote a brief synopsis about each approach to value it would help you to better understand the thought process behind each approach. There are three ways to determine the value of anything, and each plays a part in property appraisal. The most widely-used and accepted in residential practice is the sales comparison approach. This approach bases its opinion of value on what similar properties in the vicinity have sold for recently, with appropriate adjustments for time, acreage, living area, amenities and so on. It is these adjustments where the expertise of the professional appraiser becomes necessary -- no computer can tell you how much or little to mark up for a fireplace without knowing the neighborhood or even talking to Realtors and recent buyers in the area about how important that amenity is in that particular location. Another way to determine the amount of an adjustment is to do a matched paired analysis of the property and is amenities.
Another approach is the cost approach. How much would a property cost to replace, that is, rebuild, minus "accrued depreciation," that is, depreciation that has occurred since the property actually was built? The cost approach includes concepts like "economic life" and "effective age" that are mostly of use in determining the value of special use properties, special purpose properties or properties where subsequent structural improvements greatly impact value.
The third approach to value is called the income approach. Some properties generate income for their owners -- the most obvious examples being rental properties such as apartment buildings, non owner-occupied houses and duplexes. The rental income an owner might reasonably expect from a property is part of its value. For a purely owner-occupied residential property, this may not be applicable, but it can be important if the property is to be rented out or used otherwise to generate income, such as a storage facility, cell tower rental and office building.
I hope this brief description of each approach to value helps to put a brighter light on how an appraisal works. I do welcome comments, and I am open for discussions if you care to give me a call. In the mean time, I invite you to post any comments you may have to the sight.
Thanks Again for your Business,
Jeff
Mortgage fraud has made headlines locally and nationally. Most of the time, mortgage fraud involves identity theft or fraud — making a borrower appear to be somebody else, with a better job, more income or fewer debts. Somebody more credit worthy.
But some mortgage fraud involves a broker, appraiser or loan officer telling the mortgagee — the lender — and the borrower that the house is worth more than it is. This way, they can close a larger loan and make a bigger commission. Since real estate agents also usually make a percentage of the sale as commission, sometimes they can be involved. In reality, most loan officers, mortgage brokers, appraisers and real estate salespeople are ethical and would never think of engaging in mortgage fraud. But mortgage fraud of this type always originates with one of the parties who make a commission on a closed sale.
Sometimes, fraud like this can be accomplished without an appraiser involved. Honest, professional appraisal reports are simply altered, or honest, professional appraisers' signatures forged. But in reality, a deceitful appraiser often makes it easier to perpetrate mortgage fraud. At the same time, appraisers are also homeowners', lenders' and the economy's best defense against mortgage fraud.
Appraisers are paid a set fee for their work whether a deal is closed or not. Appraisers are hired by and work for the lender that is considering loaning the money to buy a house. That lender is interested in an objective, third party, professional opinion of the true value of the home. The lender needs to know that if the borrower defaults, the collateral used to secure the loan — the house — is valuable enough to cover their loss.
Appraisers do not work for individual, commissioned loan officers, mortgage brokers or real estate agents. If they did, there would be too much pressure to "make the deal work," rather than arrive at a professional, considered opinion of the market value of the property. Appraisers also do not work for borrowers, at least in the context of a mortgage loan. But borrowers work closely with mortgage brokers, loan officers and real estate agents, and benefit the most from a third party, objective valuation of the home they want to buy.
If something catastrophic happens, such as a job loss, illness, divorce or death, and a borrower can no longer make payments on the home they've mortgaged, they will need to be able to sell the home for enough money to cover the balance of their mortgage. So, nobody benefits more from an appraiser's professional opinion of value on a home than the new homeowner, even though there is no direct client relationship.
Like some mortgage brokers, loan officers and real estate salespeople, some appraisers are "bad apples" and will agree to go along with a scheme to defraud lenders and homebuyers so bigger commissions can be had. Not us and not the vast majority of appraisers. Again, the appraiser is paid a set fee whether the loan closes or not, and does not work for any of the commissioned parties to the transaction. Appraisers are therefore a homeowner's, and a lender's, best front line defense against mortgage fraud.
As always I encourage comments and feel that this blog helps us all learn how to make this a better market place and working environment for all of us. Please send ideas and topics that you would like for me to cover in future blog articles, or I welcome you to write your own that I will be glad to post on my site.
Thank you all again for your business and continued support.......Jeff
Appraisal reviews
The Federal Reserve has recently reiterated that "financial institutions must have an effective, independent real estate appraisal and evaluation program," and that appraisers performing reviews should "have the knowledge and expertise to assess compliance with the Federal Reserves appraisal regulations and guidelines." Here at Veracity Realty Services, llc, we provide appraisal review services that are independent, qualified, professional and square with the Federal Reserve's guidelines.
Appraisal reviews "should determine whether the appraisal or evaluation is appropriate for the transaction, the risk of the transaction, and whether the process by which the collateral valuation is obtained ensures independence and quality," the Fed says. They "should also indicate whether the appraisal or evaluation report is consistent with the engagement letter, which sets forth the scope of the appraisal assignment. "The Fed also notes that "some banks supplement routine reviews with post-funding evaluations of appraisal quality for some of their higher-risk or greater-value transactions as a control to assist in detecting valuation problems."
In addition to conforming our work to the forms and guidelines of our review clients, there are four Fannie Mae forms that are generally used for review services, and we can prepare an appraisal review on any of them. They include an appraisal "desk" review, a "field" review, a "short" form and a "narrative" form. Here at Veracity Realty Services, llc, we are experienced in all types of appraisal reviews, review procedures and the responsibilities of review appraisers.
We understand what makes a quality appraisal and what the most common deficiencies are, especially in our home market. At the same time, we are professional enough to recognize that our competitors in our market are capable of doing a good job! The Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) govern appraisal reviews as well as appraisal reports, and you can count on us to ethically evaluate appraisal reports performed by others. Those others may be reviewing our work, too!
In short, here at Veracity Realty Services, llc, you can rely on our independent judgment, because we offer professional, objective, ethical appraisal review services for our clients. Browse our website to learn more about our qualifications, expertise and services offered.
FHA Appraisals in New York and Pennsylvania…
If you need an FHA real estate appraiser in the New York and Pennsylvania for a purchase or refinance, we can help you. Jeffrey Scott Jacobs is a State Certified private residential appraiser and is on the FHA/HUD approved appraiser roster.
Why an FHA Appraisal?
Recent changes in the HUD FHA program have made a significant and important contribution to the mortgage market for new purchases and for the refinancing of existing mortgages, increasing the opportunities for home ownership and offering relief for home owners faced with unaffordable mortgages or tax burdens. This is a response to predatory lending practices and the increasing number of foreclosures across the country. A new program has been created to help homeowners and is known as the FHA Secure Initiative.
Jeffrey Scott Jacobs is committed to providing competent, fair and honest appraisals to assist with these efforts, and is committed to equal housing opportunity for all.
Why Go FHA?
Some lenders do not offer FHA and some salespeople discourage their buyers from using the program. This is largely due to some property restrictions (location, repairs, etc.) and up front seller costs of the past which no longer apply. Consider these changes and benefits:
With FHA there is no minimum FICO score requirement.
With FHA, if automated underwriting denies your file, that doesn't mean that you can't get the loan funded. The underwriter can make a manual decision on the file. This is the FHA advantage of flexibility of under writers discretion.
FHA allows up to 6% seller contributions and also allows temporary buy downs other programs do not allow.
Non traditional credit is also allowed through FHA and unlike Fannie Mae, one of the trade lines do not have to be rent. So you could potentially have a borrower living rent free with other forms of non traditional credit and still make the loan work.
FHA also doesn't have a maximum cap to the amount of income a borrower can make.
In the past a stigma with FHA was that the sellers ended up having to pay the majority of the closing costs, which is no longer the case. The only non allowable closing cost (cannot be paid by the borrower) is the tax service fee.
Lenders and sales agents also thought that with FHA it was more of a hassle because HUD would require all repairs even minor repairs to be fixed. This is no longer the true. The types of repairs required for FHA are now very similar to a conventional loan and many previously required inspections have been eliminated.
If the borrowers run into trouble and cannot make their payment HUD will work with the borrower on a repayment plan so they won't necessary go to foreclosure immediately.
If you are a direct lender or a mortgage broker that deals with FHA loans, Please call Jeff to discuss your FHA appraisal needs.
Foreclosure/REO appraisal
Homes in foreclosure and homes that have reverted to your institution's ownership present special appraisal challenges. At Veracity Realty Services, llc, we're more than ready and able to help.
For a property in foreclosure, you may need to know the difference between fair market value and "quick disposition" value, to know your potential charge-off liability. At Veracity Realty Services, llc, we have experience in both providing snapshots of fair market value for our mortgage lending and servicing clients as well as "quick sale" forecasts that understand your timeline.
Owners of property in foreclosure, of course, present special challenges. They may be unwilling to allow an inspection of the property. If they have abandoned the property already, they may have neglected care of the home for some time -- or worse, caused damage. We have the experience and training to deal with the special dynamics of a foreclosure appraisal, and you should not hesitate to rely on us.
For a property that has already reverted to Real Estate Owned, you likewise will be interested in a quick disposition. But you may want to know and compare three values: As-is, as repaired, and "quick sale." These represent the value of the property without any work done to it, with the work required to make the property marketable to full market value commensurate with competing properties in the area, and, somewhere in-between, with minimal investment in repairs -- selling the property quickly, probably as a "fixer-upper." Again, we understand your timeline and the unique circumstances of an REO property, as well as the special information you'll need -- competing listings, market trends, and the like.
Please browse our website to learn more about our qualifications, expertise and services offered.
We will be expanding our Service Area into New Jersey by June 1, 2008
We are always expanding our coverage area. If your company needs a particular area serviced on a regular bases in NY, NJ, or PA, let us know.....
Appraising a haunted house…..
Upon my inspection of the rear yard I found the landscaping to be littered with tombstones from the family graves. I noted the external factor as I measured the perimeter of the house. I took my photo of the rear of the house and noticed a face looking back at me from the attic window. When I removed the camera from my eye the face was gone. Thinking to myself the house was supposed to be empty, I rang the door bell before I entered. I heard footsteps scattering around in the house so I rang the doorbell again and knocked on the door this time. Nobody answered so I went inside. As I stepped in the foyer, the wood floods creaked and I noted the hard wood flooring in below average condition. Spider webs all over the place I noted that there might be an infestation and it should be checked out by an expert in that field. I entered the kitchen and noted that it was dated because of the cooking facilities only included an open fireplace and a cooking pot for witches brew. I took my photos and moved on to the basement. In the basement I found more spider webs again noting the infestation. The utilities were not existent so I made comments on the function obsolescence. I also noted that the basement was finished as a torture chamber and that the bars to hold its occupant did not allow external access. Moving back upstairs to the top floor, I entered the full bath on the top floor. Again dated, the bath was another witches brewing pot. I marked in my notes the dated features and moved on to the attic. As I suspected there was a ghostly figure in a rocking chair with her back towards me. She was rocking back and forth in the chair and asked me to approach. As I did she began to ask how much is my house worth, and then mysteriously disappeared. I left the house wondering how I was to complete the appraisal report, there were no comparable sales to be found. What kind of adjustments should be made for the grave yard, the ghosts, and the condition of the house. Thinking to myself I should have declined this job, I then woke up and realized it was just a Halloween Daydream………
Have a great day and remember that safety come first, we wish you a happy, fun and most of all a safe Halloween…….
From the staff at Veracity Realty Services……..
I sent out an e-flyer as an ad to try and promote more business. I got a lot of feedback from that e-flyer both negative and positive. The negative was that we don’t make numbers for lenders so I thought that might be a good topic open for discussion.
Most of you already know that as a courtesy to my clients, I provide a free service so that your clients wont waste there money on an appraisal that they won’t get the loan on. I do a paper search which is not considered to be an appraisal, but it gives you a range of value of where the value of what the property will appraisal for. This of course is subject to inspections, because certain external, condition, or locational factors may affect the valuation process.
The thought behind the appraised value coming in at what the property is actually worth, and not the number that you need to make the deal is for your protection. It is not our job to make deals but to protect your investment in your client. The paper search that we do cost us both time and money however, we do it for free to better serve you. If the value isn’t there and we don’t get the job, we lose.
I’ve attached a copy of the e-flyer below and would appreciate any comments on this topic.
“At Veracity Realty Services, llc, we’re not number-hitters. That’s not why our clients, like you, hire us. You hire us to be candid, professional and independent.
That’s really the role of any appraiser in the mortgage market: We’re like auditors are for publicly traded companies. During the recent historic mortgage and housing boom, too many of our colleagues fell into the trap of “working the numbers.”
At Veracity Realty Services, llc, we’re here to help you make a responsible, fully informed decision on whether to make a loan, and for how much. We can’t provide a more important service to any of our clients than to sometimes say “no,” you’re taking too much risk if you make the loan you’re being asked to make.
Confidence – your confidence in us, your borrowers’ confidence in you, the country’s confidence in its economy – that’s what the appraisal profession brings to the mortgage process. And that’s what we strive to bring you every single time you engage our services. “
We want to thank you for the opportunity to serve you and look forward to continuing to do so.
Pennsylvania Office: 4511 Graystone Drive Nazareth, PA 18064 New York Office: 663 Correl Avenue Staten Island, NY 10309
Pennsylvania Office: 4511 Graystone Drive Nazareth, PA 18064
New York Office: 663 Correl Avenue Staten Island, NY 10309
Staff Profiles | Contact Us | Appraisal Info | Value Check | FHA Appraisal | About Us... | Client Login | Order an Appraisal | Inspection Tips | How to Prepare | Tell a Friend | Why an appraisal? | Services | Home | Why Order Online? | Faster Appraisals | Our Service Area | Payment Options | My Blog | FHA Approved
Copyright © 2008 Veracity Realty Services, llcPortions Copyright © 2008 a la mode, inc.Another XSite by a la mode, inc. | Admin Login| Terms of Use| Site Map